Short answer: Positioning is the decision about which customers your product is for, what they would use if you did not exist and why you are the better choice for them. To position a B2B startup: (1) pick your best-fit customers, (2) list the real alternatives, including doing nothing and spreadsheets, (3) find the capabilities only you have, (4) translate them into value that buyers confirm in interviews, (5) choose the market frame that makes that value obvious, (6) write a positioning statement and a message hierarchy, and (7) attach proof to every claim. Then test it with win/loss notes, a five-second test of your homepage, your sales call language and conversion data. The steps follow April Dunford’s framework from Obviously Awesome, with the evidence taken from customer interviews.
In July 2026, Julian Meinke, the founder of Postelix, went through his company’s git history and counted the homepage rebuilds: seven between May 13 and July 8, one every eight days on average. Of one version, a full redesign under an unchanged headline, he wrote: “we didn’t know what to say, so we made it prettier.” He concluded that “every rebuild was a strategy change that showed up on the homepage first.”
This guide fixes that problem at the source, for founders of B2B tech companies from pre-seed to Series B. Each step covers what to do, an example and the trap to avoid. The examples follow one fictional company: a seed-stage startup whose software checks supplier invoices against contract terms before they are paid, sold to mid-size manufacturers.
What positioning is, and how it differs from messaging and brand
April Dunford, a positioning consultant who ran marketing at seven startups, defines it like this: “Positioning defines how your product is a leader at delivering something that a well-defined set of customers cares a lot about.” In plainer words, it is the context that tells buyers what your product is, who it is for and what to compare it with. Call your product a CRM, she notes, and buyers assume you compete with Salesforce and sell to the head of sales.
- Positioning is the decision about best-fit customers, the alternative you want to be compared with and the value you lead with. The CEO owns it.
- Messaging is the set of sentences that carries that decision into a homepage, a deck or a sales call. In Dunford’s words, “Positioning is not equivalent to messaging. It isn’t a tagline.”
- Brand is, in Marty Neumeier’s definition, “a person’s gut feeling about a product, service, or company.” The name, the identity and every contact with your team shape it.
Dunford breaks positioning into five components: competitive alternatives (what customers would do if you did not exist), unique capabilities (what you have that those alternatives lack), value (what those capabilities let customers achieve), best-fit customers (who cares most about that value) and market category (the context that makes the value obvious). Relevant trends are an optional sixth. In the book, a 10-step process puts them in order, starting with the customers who love your product (Commoncog’s summary covers all ten). The seven steps below follow that order and add what B2B requires: several buyers, proof for each and a version for investors.
You may know Geoffrey Moore’s fill-in-the-blanks positioning statement from Crossing the Chasm (template). Dunford calls starting with it “not only pointless but potentially dangerous,” because it assumes one known answer per blank. We use it in step 6, to summarise decisions already made.
How to position a B2B startup in seven steps
The CEO leads, with the heads of sales, product and customer success in the room. Bring a list of your best customers, recent sales call notes and last quarter’s lost deals.
Step 1: Pick your best-fit customers
What to do. List the customers who bought quickly, use the product deeply, renewed or expanded, and would recommend you. Look for what they share beyond firmographics: the situation that started the search, the team that owns the problem, the event that made it urgent. Those traits are your best-fit profile.
With many users, Sean Ellis’s survey question helps: “How would you feel if you could no longer use the product?” When Superhuman narrowed its market to the profile of users who answered “very disappointed”, its score rose from 22% to 33% on segmentation alone (First Round Review). With a few dozen accounts, interviews tell you more. Before revenue, treat the profile as a draft.
Example. The invoice-audit startup sells to logistics firms, retailers and manufacturers. The accounts that renewed early are all multi-plant manufacturers whose finance team found overcharges after an audit.
The trap. Choosing best-fit customers by the logos you want or by the size of the market. Dunford, as Commoncog summarises her, ties the width to your near-term sales target: widen the group only if it is too small to reach this year’s number.
Step 2: List the alternatives buyers really compare you with
What to do. Ask best-fit customers what they used before you and what they would do tomorrow if you disappeared. Group the answers into two to five alternatives, as Commoncog’s summary suggests. In B2B the list nearly always includes the status quo: a spreadsheet, a manual process, an outside firm or doing nothing.
Dunford writes that in enterprise software “we typically lose 25% of deals to ‘no decision.’” In an analysis of more than 2.5 million recorded sales conversations, Matthew Dixon and Ted McKenna found that 40% to 60% of deals end with customers who intended to buy but never acted (Harvard Business Review). Position against the status quo as well as against other vendors.
Example. The invoice-audit startup ends up with four alternatives: clerks spot-checking invoices in Excel, a recovery audit firm that reviews last year’s payments for a share of what it finds, the three-way match in the ERP, and accepting the leakage. None of the startups the founders follow came up in interviews.
The trap. What Dunford calls phantom competitors, companies that could compete with you in theory but never appear in your deals. Arguing against them does nothing against the spreadsheet you keep losing to.
Step 3: Find the capabilities only you have
What to do. List what you have that the alternatives from step 2 lack: features, and also data, integrations, delivery and pricing model, team expertise. Cross out anything any alternative can also do. Keep each remaining item specific enough that a customer’s engineer could check it.
Example. The invoice-audit software reads price breaks and rebates from the contracts themselves, checks every invoice line rather than a sample, and runs before payment rather than a year later. The clerks, the recovery firm and the ERP do none of the three.
The trap. Table stakes (“easy to use”, “AI-powered”) and roadmap items. In the 6sense 2025 Buyer Experience Report, 89% of purchases included AI features, and 58% of buyers contacted sellers earlier to clarify AI details the vendors had left out. If AI is part of the product, say what the model reads, what it decides and how its output is checked.
Step 4: Translate capabilities into value buyers confirm in interviews
What to do. For each capability, ask “so what?” on the customer’s behalf until you reach an outcome a budget holder would pay for, then group the answers into two or three value themes. A theme survives if several best-fit customers describe it in interviews, unprompted and in their own words.
Our guide to customer interviews for positioning has the question list and a call script. In short: talk to recent buyers, lost prospects and several roles from one buying group, ask about past behaviour rather than future opinions, and record calls with permission to keep quotes word for word. Plan calls per segment. A 2022 systematic review by Hennink and Kaiser found saturation within 9 to 17 interviews, particularly in fairly homogeneous groups with narrow questions (PubMed).
Example. “Checks every line before payment” becomes “overcharges stopped before cash leaves”, which becomes the value theme “recover margin without adding accounts payable headcount”. Finance directors describe it as finding the money before the auditors do, and accounts payable leads as getting their Fridays back. Both phrasings go into the message hierarchy.
The trap. Value in your own vocabulary (“efficiency”, “visibility”) and questions like “Would you pay for this?”, which get polite answers. “Walk me through the last time this cost you money” gets evidence.
Step 5: Choose the market frame
What to do. Pick the category that makes your value obvious to best-fit customers the moment they hear it, using one of the three styles Dunford describes (Commoncog summary):
- Head to head: you win an existing category against its leader. It takes a lot of capital.
- Big fish, small pond: you win a subsegment of a known category whose buyers have needs the leader does not meet.
- Create a new game: you define a new category, prove it should exist and then lead it.
Most startups belong in the middle. Dunford writes that 90% of tech companies that had gone public in the previous five years were positioned in existing markets rather than new ones (A Quickstart Guide to Positioning). To check a frame, say it to someone in the target role and ask which competitors and price they expect. If those assumptions are wrong, so is the frame.
Example. “Accounts payable automation” invites a comparison on breadth with large AP suites. “Spend analytics” promises dashboards. “Pre-payment invoice audit for manufacturers” says what it does and for whom, and anchors the price to money recovered rather than to seats.
The trap. Coining a category name before buyers understand the basic one, or making a trend the category. Dunford treats trends as optional and risky.
Step 6: Write the positioning statement and a message hierarchy
What to do. Write the statement now, as a summary of steps 1 to 5. We use Moore’s structure with proof added:
For [best-fit customer] who [trigger, in their words], [product] is a [market frame] that [lead value]. Unlike [main alternative], it [unique capability], and we can prove it with [evidence].
Customers never see the statement in this form. From it you write the message hierarchy, the ordered sentences the company uses to explain itself, from the one-liner down to proof and role messages (outline in the templates below). Our San Francisco positioning guide shows how each level traces back to interview answers.
Example. For finance directors at multi-plant manufacturers who find supplier overcharges only after the annual audit, [Product] is a pre-payment invoice audit that stops overcharges before money leaves the company. Unlike spreadsheet spot checks or a recovery audit a year later, it checks every invoice line against the contract terms, and we can prove it with [customer] and [amount stopped in the pilot]. The one-liner for the homepage and the title slide reads “Catch supplier overcharges before you pay them.”
The trap. Starting here, which turns assumptions into a confident sentence, or pasting the statement onto the homepage. Sequoia asks founders to “define your company in a single declarative sentence” and warns that “this is harder than it looks”. Y Combinator’s email test helps: send two sentences to a smart friend and ask them to explain it back.
Step 7: Attach proof to every claim
What to do. Give each pillar of the hierarchy the strongest evidence you have. When we reviewed 30 funded B2B startup websites, proof opened the largest gap between the best and the weakest sites, 2.9 points on a 1 to 5 scale. The strongest proof was a named customer with a number, followed by video testimonials, named quotes, customer logos, partner or investor logos, and awards and press. With few customers, use pilots with a before and after, named design partners, letters of intent, a benchmark others can rerun and certifications.
Example. Pillar: “Every line, not a sample.” Proof: “[Customer] checked [number] invoices in [period] and stopped [amount] in overcharges”, plus a quote from that customer’s finance director.
The trap. Proof that does not match the claim, such as investor logos under a sentence about savings. On 6 of the 30 sites in our study, the strongest proof was hidden or unreachable. Put it next to the claim it supports.
What is different about positioning in B2B
Several buyers read the same story. In a Gartner survey of 632 B2B buyers, buying groups ranged from five to 16 people across as many as four functions, and 74% of buyer teams showed “unhealthy conflict” during the decision. Content tailored to the buying group as a whole improved consensus by 20%, while content tailored to individual relevance had a 59% negative impact on it. Keep one positioning for the group and vary the proof by role.
| Role | What they need to believe | Proof that works |
|---|---|---|
| Users | It fits how they work and saves them time | A demo on their own data, quotes from people in the same role |
| Technical evaluators | It integrates, is secure and creates no extra work | Integration docs, architecture overview, sandbox, security page |
| Procurement and security | You are a real company that handles data properly | Legal entity, DPA, subprocessors, certifications, references |
| Budget holder | The outcome is worth the money and the risk is contained | A named customer with a number, a pilot plan with exit criteria |
Most of the decision happens without you. The 6sense 2025 report, based on more than 4,000 buyers, found average buying cycles of about 10 months, that 94% of buying groups ranked their preferred vendors before first contact, and that they bought from that early favourite 77% of the time. The homepage and the deck your champion forwards have to make sense without you in the room. We list what procurement and security reviewers look for in what enterprise procurement checks on your website.
Investors hear the same story with a different emphasis. DocSend reports that VCs spend an average of three minutes and 44 seconds on a seed deck. Focal writes that most VCs, or at least potential leads, will ask to speak to your customers during diligence, so describe the value the way those customers do. See also what investors check on your website and one story, three jobs.
| Positioning component | What buyers hear | What investors also need |
|---|---|---|
| Best-fit customers | Who it is built for | Size of the first segment, next segments |
| Competitive alternatives | What you replace and why it hurts | Why now, why incumbents have not solved it |
| Unique capabilities | What you do that others cannot | Why it is hard to copy |
| Value | The outcome and its size | Willingness to pay, retention |
| Market frame | A category they recognise | Comparable companies and their valuations |
| Proof | Case studies, pilots, references | Traction, reference calls |
How to test your positioning
Test before you rebuild the website or the deck.
Win/loss notes. After each won, lost or stalled deal, ask the buyer why they decided. Corporate Visions reports that sellers and buyers cite different reasons for lost deals 50 to 70 percent of the time. Note which alternative the buyer compared you with and which value theme they repeated back. If they name a different alternative from the one you chose in step 2, the positioning has not landed.
First-screen test. Show your homepage’s first screen for five seconds to someone in the target role, then ask what the product is, who it is for and what it replaces. Nielsen Norman Group found that a page has to communicate its value proposition within 10 seconds to hold users for several minutes. In our study, only 13 of 30 funded startup homepages were clear within 5 seconds. Repeat it with your deck’s first slide.
Sales call language. In recordings of recent calls, check whether your team uses the one-liner without reading it, whether prospects repeat it back or ask “so you’re like X?”, and which alternative they name unprompted. That alternative shows the frame they put you in.
Conversion data. Compare before and after: demo requests from the homepage, first meetings that become opportunities, win rate against your chosen alternative, deals lost to no decision and cycle length. Read these small early numbers alongside the call notes.
When to reposition
Caroline Brown’s write-up of Dunford’s book launch lists the classic symptoms: prospects compare you to companies that are not your competitors, like your special sauce but cannot say how they would use it, and the sales cycle peters out mid-funnel. Also watch for these:
- Your best customers come from a segment you never targeted. Dunford once called 100 buyers of a “Microsoft Access killer”: 94 did not know they had it, and 6 had transformed their business with it. Repositioned as an “embeddable database for mobile devices,” it took off (Dunford).
- You lose more deals to no decision than to competitors. Your case against the status quo is not landing.
- The product has outgrown its headline, through a new capability or a new buyer.
- Your next milestone needs a different audience: enterprise buyers, the US or DACH market or investors who know a different category.
- The homepage headline changes every few weeks, as in Meinke’s list of rebuilds.
Wait if you are still choosing between segments or the product changes every month: write the best one-liner you can and revisit it later, as in what to fix first after a seed round.
Templates
Positioning canvas
Fill in one canvas per segment, and write the evidence next to every answer.
| Component | Question to answer | Your answer | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best-fit customers | Who bought fastest, uses the product most and would be very disappointed without it? | Account names, interview count | |
| Trigger | What happened just before they started looking? | Quotes | |
| Competitive alternatives | What would they do without us, including nothing? | Interviews, lost-deal notes | |
| Unique capabilities | What do we have that those alternatives lack? | Demo, documentation, benchmark | |
| Value themes | What does each capability let customers achieve, in their words? | Quotes, customer numbers | |
| Market frame | Which category makes that value obvious? | What buyers assumed on hearing it | |
| Relevant trend (optional) | Does a trend make this more urgent now? | Source | |
| Proof | What evidence supports each value theme? | Case study, pilot, reference | |
| Not for | Which customers do we turn away? | Churn and lost-deal patterns |
Message hierarchy outline
| Level | What to write | Length | Where it is used |
|---|---|---|---|
| One-liner | What it is and the outcome | One sentence | Homepage headline, title slide, LinkedIn |
| Lead value | The outcome best-fit customers mention first | One or two sentences | Hero subhead, first line of the pitch |
| Three pillars | Why the lead value is credible, each tied to a unique capability | Headline plus two sentences | Homepage sections, solution slide |
| Proof per pillar | The strongest evidence for each pillar | One line plus a link | Next to each pillar, traction slide |
| Role messages | What each buyer role needs | A paragraph per role | Role pages, sales deck |
| Investor layer | Market size, why now, business model, traction | One slide each | Pitch deck |
| Objection answers | Replies to the doubts that stalled deals | Two or three sentences | FAQ, sales notes |
How we do it at dp.vision
dp.vision is a brand, web and product studio for funded, founder-led B2B tech companies from pre-seed to Series B. Every project starts with interviews with our client’s real customers, and the strategist who runs them stays on through the website and the deck. Validate (customer interviews, research and a written recommendation) starts at $2,500. Positioning with customer interviews, brand identity and an 8-10 page website usually costs about $20,000-35,000, at one fixed price agreed before work starts. The breakdown is in how much dp.vision costs.
SkyInspection inspects bridges, wind turbines and refineries with autonomous drones. We moved its promise from drone inspection to failure prediction. After the new positioning and website went live, the company received 23 inbound demo requests in three months and signed 2 enterprise pilots, as reported by the client.
To compare studios, see our guide to brand strategy and positioning agencies in San Francisco and our ranking of branding agencies that use AI in their work. To talk through your own positioning, get in touch.
Frequently asked questions
What is positioning for a B2B startup?
Positioning is the decision about which customers your product is for, what they would use without you and why you are the better choice. April Dunford breaks it into competitive alternatives, unique capabilities, value, best-fit customers and market category.
What is the difference between positioning, messaging and brand?
Positioning is the decision: who the product is for, what it is compared with and why it wins. Messaging is the language that carries that decision into a homepage, a deck or a sales call. Brand is what people feel about the company. Work on them in that order.
How long does it take to position a B2B startup?
In our experience, one to two weeks of focused work for a seed-stage team, longer if you interview several buyer roles. Then test it for a few weeks in sales calls and on the homepage before rebuilding the website or deck.
Can you position a startup before it has paying customers?
Yes, as a draft. Interview prospects and design partners who match your best-fit profile, treat what they do today as the alternative, and update the positioning when pilots show who gets the most value.
Should a B2B startup create a new market category?
Usually not at the start. April Dunford writes that 90% of tech companies that had gone public in the previous five years were positioned in existing markets. A subsegment of a known category is faster to understand and cheaper to explain.
How many customer interviews do you need for positioning?
Plan the number per segment. A 2022 systematic review found that 9 to 17 interviews usually reach saturation in a fairly homogeneous group with a narrow question. If users and budget holders see the product differently, treat them as separate groups.
When should a startup reposition?
When prospects compare you to the wrong alternative, deals end in no decision, your best customers come from a segment you never targeted or the product has outgrown its headline. Moving upmarket, a new market or a new round are reasons too.
Do investors and buyers need different positioning?
No, the same positioning with different emphasis. Investors also want market size, why now and evidence that customers pay. Many VCs ask to speak with your customers during diligence, so both versions have to match.
Sources
- April Dunford, A Quickstart Guide to Positioning
- April Dunford, Obviously Awesome
- Commoncog, Obviously Awesome: Comprehensive Book Summary
- Caroline Brown, How Do You Know If You Have A Positioning Problem?, Business of Software
- University of Cambridge, Institute for Manufacturing, The Elevator Speech (Geoffrey Moore’s positioning template)
- Marty Neumeier, The Brand Gap: Take-Home Lessons
- Julian Meinke, post on seven homepage rebuilds, LinkedIn, July 2026
- Rahul Vohra, How Superhuman Built an Engine to Find Product/Market Fit, First Round Review
- Matthew Dixon and Ted McKenna, Stop Losing Sales to Customer Indecision, Harvard Business Review, 2022
- Hennink and Kaiser (2022), Sample sizes for saturation in qualitative research: a systematic review of empirical tests, Social Science & Medicine
- 6sense, 2025 Buyer Experience Report announcement
- Gartner, Gartner Sales Survey Finds 74% of B2B Buyer Teams Demonstrate “Unhealthy Conflict” During the Decision Process, May 2025
- Sequoia Capital, Writing a Business Plan
- Y Combinator, How to Pitch Your Company
- DocSend, What VCs Really Want to See Inside Your Seed Deck
- Focal, How to Go About Customer Reference Asks
- Corporate Visions, The Business Case for Win-Loss Analysis
- Nielsen Norman Group, How Long Do Users Stay on Web Pages?
